DEL Daily News
DEL Time: 13:40
Request For: Pro and College Baseball|
Request Title: NL Pitcher bunting
Would love to see either a setting for Pitchers bunting preference or just enhance the sim to support pitchers automatically bunting with runners on first base and less than 2 outs.
Had a situation in today's game where we had runners on 1st and 2nd with no outs. Pitcher comes up and hits into a double play and killed the inning. I intentionally have my bunts to less for position players but would want to have my pitcher move the runners over via bunt vs. swing away.
Submitted Jan 18 15:15:34 2019
by John Henry
Coaches In Favor of Change: John Henry, Coach Jackson, Darryll Johnston, Johnny Gunn, Loren Smith
Coaches Opposed to Change: none
Loren Smith: I think John's request is to have one setting for position players coming up to bat that can be different than the pitcher. I tend to agree with him, I want my pitcher almost always bunting with less than two out. But, I rarely want my position players doing so, especially my middle of the order power hitters.
3Dec19 Follow up:
I generally think Andy's proposal is an improvement. What work effort would there be in also building in a game situation measure for non-pitchers? I may want increased bunting when tied or down by 1 late in the game; but, maybe never when down by 3 or more.
John Henry: Sacrifice bunt: Least
To clarify I only want position players to bunt in a game winning situation, so all of my settings are 'Least' except late/tied.
The only exception is the above scenario is with my pitcher. I want them bunting most unless there is two outs. In the AL you don;t have this issue so probably just don't see it happen as often as our NL games.
This is the perfect example...todays game. To be fair he flew out with 2 strikes so not 100% sure he wasn't bunting but this would have been a prime spot for this.
Bases empty. No outs.
Batter: Viola (0.258 BA, 11 HR, 33 RBI, 0.304 OBA)
Viola on 1. No outs.
Batter: Desimone (0.000 BA, 0 HR, 0 RBI, 0.000 OBA)
infield drawn in.
Fly ball to Camacho (CF).
I like the proposal seems to solve the issue.
Status: Completed (last updated Jan 11 18:16:39 2020
Priority: Short Term
Additional criteria for sacrifice bunts have been added to the baseball sim. In addition to the existing criteria (hit is unlikely, never bunt with a man on third, with nobody on first or second, two outs, or bunts set to "never" in the coaching options), the following criteria apply based on position (pitcher vs. non-pitcher).
- Never: never bunt
- Less: man on first, second open
- Normal, More, Most: no additional criteria
- Never, Less, Normal: never bunt
- More: man on first, second base open, no outs, tied or down one
- Most: man on first, second base open, no outs
The help pages have been updated to reflect the additional criteria.